Same Electricity Plan, Two Renewable Percentages

We run ElectricityFinder, a site that compares Texas electricity plans, so our software reads each plan's fact sheet. The fact sheet (its official name is the Electricity Facts Label, or EFL) says what percentage of the plan's electricity comes from renewable sources like wind and solar. Power to Choose, the state's plan-comparison website, lists a renewable percentage for each plan too. Usually the two match. Sometimes they don't.

What each one says about one plan

Where you look What it says
Power to Choose 26% renewable
The plan's fact sheet 23.9% renewable

Same plan, two answers. If you want a plan that's at least 25% renewable, one says this plan qualifies and the other says it doesn't. It doesn't change the price. It changes whether the plan looks like it meets your goal.

How often it happens

We compared 930 plans' fact sheets with their Power to Choose listings. A percentage point is the plain difference between two percentages: 26% and 23.9% are 2.1 percentage points apart.

What we found Plans
Same number, or 1 percentage point apart or less (like 25.5% and 26%) 884
More than 1 percentage point apart (like 23.9% and 26%) 46

The 46 plans come from 3 providers, and in 45 of them Power to Choose lists the higher number.

We didn't find out which number is right, or why they differ. We can see what each fact sheet prints and what Power to Choose lists. Only the provider can say which number applies to its plan.

Don't confuse it with the statewide average

A fact sheet also lists a statewide average. The one for the plan above lists 37.2%, on the line right after the plan's own percentage. That's the average for all electricity generated in Texas, published each spring by ERCOT, the state's grid operator. It's there for comparison: this plan's 23.9% is below it. It isn't the plan's own percentage.

What ElectricityFinder shows

We can't say which number is right, so for most of the 46 we show both. When the two are still more than a percentage point apart after rounding both to whole numbers, we show the fact sheet's number and give Power to Choose's in a note. For the plan above, you'd see 24% (the fact sheet's 23.9%, rounded) and the note "From this plan's Electricity Facts Label. Power to Choose lists 26%."

That's 40 of the 46 plans. For the other 6, the fact sheet's 24.7% rounds to 25%, within a percentage point of Power to Choose's 26%, so we show 26%. Plans Power to Choose lists as 100% renewable are an exception: we show 100%.

Before you pick a plan for its renewable percentage

  1. Open the plan's fact sheet (its EFL), linked from the plan's listing here or on Power to Choose.
  2. Find the renewable percentage for this plan. The fact sheet may call it "this product." Skip the statewide average.
  3. If it doesn't match Power to Choose, ask the provider which number applies to the plan you'd sign up for.

Compare plans at your own usage.

Enter your monthly usage or upload your Smart Meter Texas data. The calculator prices the plans listed on Power to Choose for your utility, as of our most recent update, against your usage.

Compare Plans Now

Where the numbers come from

Compare plans in your city: Dallas, Fort Worth, Houston, Corpus Christi.